Wi-Fi antenna extender hack
You know that someone is going to cry fraud any time there's a how-to on extending wi-fi range. And this one is no exception (read the Comments). I don't know why people doing these projects don't show before and after readings on a signal strength meter to prove their claims. I'm not a radio engineer or a ham, so I can't really judge without trying this out for myself on a spare antenna. I'd be interested to know what MAKE readers think who have experience in this area.
WIFI Antenna Hack! - Link
Related:
- Other wif-fi antenna coverage on MAKE: Blog - Link
Posted by Gareth Branwyn |
Sep 28, 2007 05:00 AM
DIY Projects, Electronics, Wireless |
Permalink
| Comments (10)
| Email This |
| Digg this!
Recent Entries
- Best of CRAFT
- 10 Things 3D printers can do now
- How to nap
- GeekDad at Maker Faire
- Sugarcube sculptures
- Set your clocks back it's Standard time again...
- Pedal to a cold drink...
- Austin Event: DJ/Laptop Battle
- Single-Wheeled Bike Trailer
- Gear heart
Comments
Oldest comments listed first.
| Posted by: Bil.Kleb@nasa.gov on September 28, 2007 at 5:50 AM |
This looks like a transformation from a simple whip antenna to a J-pole antenna, but I'd consult homebrew antenna master of the aviation world: Jim Weir of RST Engineering.
| Posted by: wa8wte on September 28, 2007 at 6:22 AM |
Read Jeff Duntemann, K7JPD's book,
Wi-Fi Drive-By Guide...many
antenna projects, or just read a good amateur radio UHF antenna book....
woof woof, George, WA8WTE
| Posted by: kylecroft on September 28, 2007 at 6:45 AM |
I'm not quite sure that an antenna can double your power output, but I could be wrong
| Posted by: jbond on September 28, 2007 at 7:26 AM |
I've built a few and the only ones that made any worthwhile difference were a waveguide made from a premium brand Whisky container and a Bi-Quad. None of the toothpick designs gave enough gain to make much difference at all. It may be that commercial omnis are worth it, but I couldn't make them accurately enough to succeed. And 5dB difference is pretty hard to see in the real world of PCs and Wifi.
| Posted by: NGinuity on September 28, 2007 at 8:17 AM |
"I'm not quite sure that an antenna can double your power output, but I could be wrong"
You can double your power output by increasing your gain in a field of radiation by 3dB. Of course, it decreases it from somewhere else in the model, but generally speaking, it is somewhere like the extreme top and bottom where coverage is not needed. The more gain you have on the sides of an antenna, the more of a coverage null you will have on the top and bottom, or vice versa.
| Posted by: Tek465m on September 28, 2007 at 12:03 PM |
Looks like a vertical antenna with a load coil. I'm not sure how you could measure efficency without at least looking at SWR. I don't see a groundplane; anything near it would change the pattern.
2.4 GHz is pretty unforgiving dimensionally for any frequency, just a mm or two will throw off SWR and completely change your radiation pattern. Plus it has to be a wideband system since it uses Spread Spectrum of over a hundred MHz.
A good program to model an antenna is at
http://mmhamsoft.amateur-radio.ca/
Look for MMANA-GAL. It works best for lower frequencies, but it will give you an idea of how shapes affect antennas.
| Posted by: dragonphyre on September 28, 2007 at 12:36 PM |
I call shenanigans as well. I had an extra base here for my router, and for my wireless NIC. I made up two of these antennas, and tested them in every possible configuration.
Conclusion: Negligible improvements, could be attributed to error. I placed the laptop in the same spot for each test, but I had to move the router around quite a bit to get the new antennas in place. Also, the new antennas were significantly more 'flimsy' and were easily bent out of shape--which made SNR TERRIBLE.
It would be a better idea to move the router to a much better location, and give it a bigger antenna than to mess with your laptop's antenna anyway.
| Posted by: 928Quest on October 1, 2007 at 1:28 PM |
Yes it can double the power. Antennas can have "gain" but as the poster above said it is because you are taking the power and concetrating it. There are antenna designs that can do far more than double, look up "yagi" for instance.
There is an error in this report howver. Doubling the power does not double the range. For this type of antenna doubling the power will get you a little more range but not double.
| Posted by: skeptical on March 17, 2008 at 1:17 PM |
I doubt that antenna will even help. youll probably make your cheap antenna worse by adding poor quality wire and bad connecting methods you will lose gain and pickup more nose. More noise will be received due to the sheer inconsistency of the above design as screws taper and have different angles and distance between teeth this depends on sheer luck. If you have never used a soldering iron or taken anything apart your wasting your time because it could take hours of fine tuning and even then it could be a total flop.
Leave a comment
Subscribe to MAKE Magazine!
Subscribe today, save 42% and get web access to MAKE free. MAKE Digital Edition is available only to subscribers.
$34.95 / 1 year
(4 Quarterly Issues)
Features and more @ MAKE!

Stop by the Maker Shed store and check out THE place for open source hardware, Arduino & Arduino accessories, electronic kits, science kits, smart stuff for kids, back issues of MAKE & CRAFT, box sets, books, robots, kits from Japan and more.
Add MAKE to iGoogle - GoogleGoogle.
Add MAKE to your RSS reader - Real simple.
Add MAKE on Twitter.
Add MAKE on FriendFeed & the MAKE room.

Why advertise on MAKE?
Read what folks are saying about us!
Click here to advertise on MAKE!
Makezine authors!
Phillip Torrone
Senior Editor
Tel: 707-827-7311
Twitter / AIM
Gareth Branwyn
Jonah Brucker-Cohen
Collin Cunningham
Marc de Vinck
Kip Kay
Luke Iseman
Patti Schiendelman
Becky Stern
Mike Dixon
Peter Horvath(intern)


